Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) affects approximately 10 percent of women of child-bearing age. Use of progesterone in the treatment of the symptoms of PMS has been advocated, even though trials have not shown that it is more effective than placebo, except for relief of the specific symptoms of hot flushes, water retention and swelling. In contrast, some studies have shown that alprazolam, an anxiolytic/antipanic medication, is effective in the treatment of PMS. In a randomized, double-blind trial, Freeman and colleagues compared the effectiveness of oral micronized progesterone with that of alprazolam and placebo in the treatment of PMS.
A total of 444 women seen at an outpatient obstetrics-gynecology department requested evaluation for PMS and were instructed to record their symptoms for two cycles. Women were included in the study if they were between 18 and 45 years of age, had regular menses and had moderate to severe symptoms of PMS for at least six months. After tracking symptoms for two cycles, the women had two office evaluations; after evaluation, 284 of these women still met criteria for the study. Placebo was then given to each of these patients. Of the 284 women, 56 had a placebo response and were excluded from the study, and 43 dropped out for other reasons, leaving 185 (42 percent of the original group) who completed the study
Seventeen different symptoms were rated daily on a scale of zero (for lack of a symptom) to four (for severe symptoms). Premenstrual and postmenstrual scores were calculated, based on five-day periods before and after menses. PMS was defined as a premenstrual score of at least 70, a premenstrual score at least 50 percent greater than the postmenstrual score and premenstrual functional impairment. Patients were randomized to receive three cycles of either 1,200 mg of oral micronized progesterone or 1.0 mg of alprazolam or placebo, each given in divided doses. Dosage increases were allowed in subsequent cycles. Treatment was given from the 18th day until the onset of menstruation, with a dosage taper at the beginning of menses. Follow-up included either a brief (20-minute) or extended (50-minute) visit with a clinician. Evaluation consisted of a review of the premenstrual symptom scores with attention to symptoms in the following categories: mood, mental function, pain, food craving and physical symptoms.
Side effects of treatment were reported by 88 percent of women who received progesterone, 79 percent of women who received alprazolam and 55 percent of women who received placebo. At the end of the three-month treatment period, women in the alprazolam group showed significantly lower symptom scores than women in either of the other groups. Progesterone therapy, as expected, caused improvement of physical symptoms such as breast engorgement and swelling. Symptoms did not differ between women who had brief follow-up visits and those who had extended visits. The change in scores after three months of treatment showed that 37 percent of the alprazolam group, 30 percent of the placebo group and 29 percent of the progesterone group had a 50 percent improvement in scores. In contrast, only 7 percent of women in the alprazolam group had worse symptoms at the end of the three months, compared with 28 percent of the placebo group and 23 percent of the progesterone group.
The authors conclude that the use of alprazolam during the luteal phase can effectively diminish symptoms of PMS and, if used in a sparing manner, the risk of dependence associated with benzodiazepines would be lessened. (JAMA, July 5, 1995, vol. 274, p. 51.)
COPYRIGHT 1995 American Academy of Family Physicians
COPYRIGHT 2004 Gale Group
Contact
Home
A
8-Hour Bayer