Vulvodynia is a problem most family physicians can expect to encounter. It is a syndrome of unexplained vulvar pain, frequently accompanied by physical disabilities, limitation of daily activities, sexual dysfunction and psychologic distress. The patient's vulvar pain usually has an acute onset and, in most cases, becomes a chronic problem lasting months to years. The pain is often described as burning or stinging, or a feeling of rawness or irritation. Vulvodynia may have multiple causes, with several subsets, including cyclic vulvovaginitis, vulvar vestibulitis syndrome, essential (dysesthetic) vulvodynia and vulvar dermatoses. Evaluation should include a thorough history and physical examination as well as cultures for bacteria and fungus, KOH microscopic examination and biopsy of any suspicious areas. Proper treatment mandates that the correct type of vulvodynia be identified. Depending on the specific diagnosis, treatment may include fluconazole, calcium citrate, tricyclic antidepressants, topical corticosteroids, physical therapy with biofeedback, surgery or laser therapy. Since vulvodynia is often a chronic condition, regular medical follow-up and referral to a support group are helpful for most patients.
Vulvodynia is frequently misdiagnosed. In a general gynecologic practice population, the prevalence of this condition may be as high as 15 percent.1 Before the 1980s, very little was written about vulvodynia. In the 1980s, renewed interest was generated with the publication of articles by Friedrich, Lynch and McKay.2-4
Vulvodynia is a syndrome of unexplained vulvar pain that is frequently accompanied by physical disabilities, limitation of daily activities (such as sitting and walking), sexual dysfunction and psychologic disability.2 Originally suggested by McKay,4 the term "vulvodynia" has also been suggested by the International Society for the Study of Vulvar Disease Task Force to describe any vulvar pain. The incidence and prevalence of vulvodynia have not been well studied.1 Age distribution for the condition may range from the 20s to the 60s, and it is limited almost exclusively to white women.2 Obstetric and gynecologic history is usually unremarkable. Risk-taking sexual behavior is rare, and few patients have a history of sexually transmitted diseases.5 Vulvar pain usually has an acute onset, at times associated with episodes of vaginitis or certain therapeutic procedures of the vulva (cryotherapy or laser therapy). In most cases, vulvodynia becomes a chronic problem lasting months to years. Vulvar pain is frequently described as burning or stinging, or a feeling of rawness or irritation.4
Most patients consult several physicians before being diagnosed. Many are treated with multiple topical or systemic medications, with minimal relief. In some cases, inappropriate therapy may even make the symptoms worse.6 Since physical findings are few and cultures and biopsies are frequently negative, patients may be told that the problem is primarily psychologic, thus invalidating their pain and adding to their distress.7(pp1-15)
Diagnostic and Management Challenges illustrative case 1
A 23-year-old woman was treated twice for a suspected urinary tract infection while traveling in Europe. The patient did not know what antiobiotic she had taken. On returning to the United States, she continued to experience dysuria and urgency with vaginal soreness, slight itching and dyspareunia. Urinalyses, urine cultures and vaginal and cervical cultures were negative. Over the course of two months, the patient went to emergency departments twice and visited four different family physicians. She was treated with numerous antibiotics, including trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, cephalexin and ciprofloxacin, for presumed cystitis. She also was treated with oral fluconazole and over-the-counter topical anticandidal preparations for presumed candidal infection, with only temporary relief. During the following two months, the patient experienced dyspareunia with intermittent vulvar pain and irritation. She subsequently saw four gynecologists, a urologist and two primary care physicians. Pelvic examination revealed erythema of the posterior fourchette and a reaction of mild tenderness on swab test. A biopsy of this area was normal. The patient was treated with doxycycline for possible cervicitis; the symptoms were not relieved. She was then given a diagnosis of vulvodynia and was prescribed gradually increasing dosages of amitriptyline, along with oral calcium gluconate three times daily and a low-oxalate diet. She was referred to a support group for persons with vulvodynia and to a physical therapist specializing in women's health problems for pelvic strengthening, relaxation training and biofeedback training. Over the next three months, the patient reported a 70 to 90 percent improvement in her symptoms, with occasional mild exacerbations.
illustrative case 2
A 45-year-old woman with a history of one term pregnancy developed urgency, erythema in the vulvar area and irritation at the base of the clitoris that began suddenly after intercourse one evening. Subsequent symptoms included burning, rawness and dyspareunia, which increased with walking, sitting and intercourse, and also increased one week before menses. The use of terconazole cream caused further burning and irritation. Over the next five months the patient saw a nurse practitioner and two family physicians. She received treatment numerous times for yeast vaginitis and bacterial vaginosis with topical antifungal medications, fluconazole and metronidazole gel. Any improvement was temporary, and the symptoms invariably returned. Vaginal cultures grew various enteric organisms, and no yeasts were detected on KOH examination. Conjugated estrogen vaginal cream gave no significant relief. Over the following two months the patient saw two gynecologists and was diagnosed with vestibulitis. She was treated with triamcinolone- nystatin cream for two months and felt improvement in the first week but later developed further irritation of the vulvar and clitoral area. No biopsies were performed. She was referred to a third gynecologist, who instructed her to stop all topical medications. She began taking calcium citrate three times daily, started a low-oxalate diet and was referred to a vulvar pain support group. Over the next year, she was treated with fluconazole, 150 mg once weekly for two months, and then once every other week for two months. She also began biofeedback training and physical therapy for pelvic muscle relaxation and strengthening. The patient underwent a total of two and one half years of treatment. During her last year of treatment, she experienced a 90 percent improvement in symptoms.
Subsets of Vulvodynia
Several subsets of vulvodynia have been identified.4,8 Since vulvodynia is a multifactorial condition, certain subsets may also coexist with others. Proper treatment necessitates appropriate identification by clinicians (Table 1).6
vulvar vestibulitis syndrome
Vulvar vestibulitis syndrome is also known as adenitis or focal vulvitis. It is characterized by entry dyspareunia, discomfort at the opening of the vagina, a positive swab test, tenderness localized within the vulvar vestibulum, and focal or diffuse vestibular erythema6,8 (Figures 1 and 2).
Chronic vestibulitis lasts for months to years, and patients may experience entry dyspareunia and pain when attempting to insert a tampon.6,8 The etiology of vulvar vestibulitis syndrome is unknown. Some cases seem to be provoked by yeast vaginitis. Other suspected causes include recent use of chemical irritants, a history of destructive therapy such as carbon dioxide laser or cryotherapy, or allergic drug reactions.5 When surgical specimens were evaluated by polymerase chain reaction, human papillomavirus was present in many women with vulvar vestibulitis syndrome.9-13
Histologic examination of symptomatic vestibular tissue has confirmed the presence of mixed chronic inflammatory infiltrates in the superficial stroma, but inflammatory cells have not been found to invade the vestibular glands or gland lumens, vessels or nerves.2
Cyclic vulvovaginitis is probably the most common cause of vulvodynia and is believed to be caused by a hypersensitivity reaction to Candida.14,15 While vaginal smears and cultures are not consistently positive, microbiologic proof should be sought by obtaining candidal or fungal cultures during an asymptomatic phase. Pain is typically worse just before or during menstrual bleeding. It also may be exacerbated after intercourse, especially on the following day.4,8 Findings on pelvic or colposcopic examination are usually normal. The diagnosis of cyclic vulvitis is made retrospectively based on the patient's report of cyclic symptomatic flare-ups (or, conversely, symptom-free days). The diagnosis is suggested prospectively by the patient's report of symptomatic improvement after the administration of long-term topical or systemic anticandidal therapy.3
dysesthetic vulvodynia Dysesthetic vulvodynia (essential vulvodynia) typically occurs in women who are peri- or postmenopausal.16 Pain that occurs in women with this subtype of vulvodynia is usually a diffuse, unremitting, burning pain that is not cyclic. Patients with dysesthetic vulvodynia have less dyspareunia or point tenderness than patients with vulvar vestibulitis syndrome.16 The physical examination shows no evidence of vestibulitis or cutaneous changes.6 Urethral or rectal discomfort is often associated with vulvar pain.5 The hyperesthesia is believed to result from altered cutaneous perception, either centrally or at the nerve root. Patients describe burning pain similar to that occurring in cases of postherpetic neuralgia or glossodynia (burning tongue syndrome).16 Some authors believe that pudendal neuralgia (pain along the pudendal nerve) is one of the causes of essential vulvodynia.17
Vulvar dermatoses may be manifested by itching and, in some cases, pain (Figures 3 through 5). Vulvar dermatoses include papulosquamous (thick and scaly) lesions. Erosions or ulcers may result from excessive scratching. If the patient has blisters or ulcers and denies scratching, the cause may be a vesiculobullous disease. Differential diagnoses of papulosquamous lesions and vesiculobullous lesions are included in Table 2.6 Neoplastic lesions include extramammary Paget's disease, squamous cell carcinoma, lichen sclerosis and vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia.6 Colposcopy and biopsy as indicated are recommended to rule out dermatoses or neoplastic lesions (Figure 6). A recent study showed the most common cause of symptomatic vulvar disease (itching or burning) to be dermatitis or another dermatosis.18
Vestibular papillomatosis is the term describing the presence of multiple small (1- to 3-mm) papillae over the entire inner labia (Figure 7). These papillae are probably congenital in origin and are a normal anatomic variant.19 A link with human papillomavirus has not been confirmed.20,21 Patients with vulvar pain and papillomatosis should undergo a colposcopically directed biopsy to rule out pathology. The significance of papillomatosis identified in the vulvar vestibule with acetowhitening is uncertain.22
The evaluation of patients with vulvar vestibulitis or vulvodynia should include a thorough history, pelvic examination, fungal and bacterial cultures, and KOH microscopic examination. Biopsy of any suspicious areas should be performed using acetowhitening and/or colposcopy to rule out dermatoses or neoplastic lesions.6 A swab test (which involves palpation of the vestibulum with a moist, cotton-tipped swab) may elicit point tenderness or sharp pain in the posterior vestibulum, the anterior vestibulum, or both.6
In patients with vulvar vestibulitis, erythema may commonly be visualized at the 5 and 7 o'clock positions or on a horseshoe-shaped area of the lower vestibulum.23 The vestibule comprises the area between the labia minora and the hymenal ring, which marks the beginning of the vaginal mucous membrane. It extends from the frenulum of the clitoris anteriorly to the fourchette of the vaginal introitus posteriorly. This area includes the Bartholin's glands, Skene's glands and numerous minor vestibular glands (Figure 8).
Treatment and Management of Vulvodynia and Vulvar Vestibulitis
Some treatments are specific to the subtype of vulvodynia that can be most closely associated with the patient. Vulvodynia is multifactorial in cause, and each subset probably has a different etiology. Cyclic vulvovaginitis is believed to be a reaction to yeast, which may be detected at times and not detected at other times with KOH preparation or fungal cultures. Some physicians may use a test for anticandidal antibodies in directing treatment. Because of the link with Candida, treatment for cyclic vulvovaginitis may include anticandidal medication even if cultures are not positive. One regimen is fluconazole (Diflucan), 150 mg orally once weekly for two months and then once every other week for two months. Other anticandidal agents that may be used include long- term therapy with topical nystatin (Micostatin Cream, Mytrex Cream), miconazole nitrate (Monistat-Derm Cream) and clotrimazole (Lotrimin).4 Vulvar vestibulitis syndrome has been treated successfully in some cases with topical estrogen cream (about a pea-sized amount), applied two times a day for four to eight weeks, or longer. Intralesional injections of interferon in 13 women with vulvar vestibulitis resulted in significant improvement of dyspareunia in 50 percent.24 Severe, recalcitrant cases may be treated with vestibulectomy or laser therapy. Tricyclic agents (amitriptyline [Elavil], imipramine [Tofranil] or desipramine [Norpramin]) have been successful in the treatment of dysesthetic vulvodynia. A recommended regimen begins with 10 mg daily, gradually increasing to 40 to 60 mg daily. Patients should continue taking the highest tolerable dosage that gives symptom relief for four to six months and then gradually decrease the dosage to the minimum amount required to control symptoms.14 Since some patients do not wish to take a psychiatric drug, it is important to explain that the medication is being used for its effect on cutaneous nerves. In one study, the average time required for effective treatment with amitriptyline was seven months, after which therapy was either discontinued or tapered.14
Other treatments that have been helpful in patients with vulvodynia are a low-oxalate diet and, in some cases, the addition of oral calcium citrate (Citracal), two tablets (200 mg/950 mg each) orally three times a day to neutralize oxalates in the urine. One theory is that oxalate may irritate the vestibulum and may be a contributing cause to vulvodynia pain over a long period.7(p16), 25
Therapy with potent topical corticosteroids should be limited to brief or short-term use. Long-term use may induce telangiectasias, skin friability, striae formation and easy bruising. Potent steroids can also cause periorificial dermatitis, a rebound inflammatory reaction with erythema and a burning sensation that occurs as the steroid is withdrawn. A cycle of vulvar dermatitis may become worse as the patient treats the erythema and discomfort with the same potent topical steroids that started the problem.6 Self-help tips for patients with vulvodynia vulvar vestibulitis are included in the patient information handout that follows this article. Physical Therapy and Biofeedback
Since vaginal muscle spasm aggravates the pain and discomfort of vulvodynia, physical therapy using biofeedback and gynecologic instruments has been successful in many patients with vaginismus (spasm of the vaginal muscle) and instability of the pelvic floor. Biofeedback training helps patients learn exercises to strengthen weakened pelvic floor muscles and to relax these same muscles, with a resultant reduction in pain.
Surgical and Laser Therapy
Laser or surgical treatment should be reserved for use in cases in which all forms of medical treatment have failed. Many cases of vulvar vestibulitis that are refractive to medical therapy respond to vulvar vestibulectomy or treatment with excited dye laser. According to Marinoff and Turner,26 surgery should be reserved for use in patients with pain of at least six months' duration, pain that partly or completely prevents sexual intercourse and patients who have undergone failed treatment for a specific subset of vulvodynia or in whom no cause can be established. Surgical excision of vulvar tissue containing vestibular glands has been reported to alleviate symptoms in up to two thirds of patients.24,27 Complications include wound hematoma, partial or complete wound dehiscence, uneven healing requiring minor revision, and stenosis of the Bartholin's duct with cyst formation.26
Flashlamp-excited dye laser therapy for the treatment of idiopathic vulvodynia has been used with some success and may reduce the need for resective surgery in many cases.28
Vulvodynia may cause drastic alterations in lifestyles. It may decrease the patient's ability to walk, exercise, sit for long periods or participate in sexual activities. All of these normal activities may exacerbate the vulvar pain.5 Many women with vulvodynia have been diagnosed with a psychologic problem because of the lack of physical findings.15 Patients may become anxious or angry as diagnosis is delayed after numerous physician visits and as their concerns increase that the condition may be a serious health problem. Many patients with vulvodynia worry that they will never recover.
The prevalence of physical and sexual abuse in patients with vulvodynia does not appear to be increased.29 Family physicians can be of immense help by making the diagnosis of vulvodynia as early as possible, identifying a specific subtype, educating the patient and beginning a management plan. Patients should be supported with the acknowledgement that vulvodynia does not appear to be a psychosomatic condition and that it has no predisposition toward cancer or other life-threatening conditions. It should be explained that improvement will occur with appropriate treatment, but that successful treatment may take months or years, and patients may have intermittent exacerbations and remissions.
Many patients benefit from referral to a group that provides information and emotional support. Final Comment
Research indicates that vulvodynia and vulvar vestibulitis are being identified by physicians with increasing frequency. Since the physician "sees only what he already knows," family physicians must be aware of and recognize this condition early. Failure to consider vulvodynia as the cause of vulvar pain is the most common reason for misdiagnosis. Vulvodynia is a multifactorial problem with subsets that may overlap. Proper management is based on identification of the subsets of vulvodynia and identification of any concurrent infections that may be appropriately treated. Family physicians working together with gynecologists who are experienced in treating patients with vulvodynia can properly diagnose vulvodynia, identify subsets and institute the management plan that can best benefit the patient. Family physicians are in an ideal position to help and support the patient psychologically with validation, education and referral to support groups. Appropriate medical treatment should be instituted and, when indicated, physical therapy with biofeedback training should be considered.
More research is needed to further identify patients with subsets of vulvodynia and to evaluate various treatment modalities.
Figures 3 through 7 from Apgar BS, Cox JT. Differentiating normal and abnormal findings of the vulva. Am Fam Physician 1996;53:1171.
1. Goetsch MF. Vulvar vestibulitis: prevalence and historic features in a general gynecologic practice population. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1991;164:1609-16.
2. Friedrich EG Jr. Vulvar vestibulitis syndrome. J Reprod Med 1987;32:110-4.
3. Lynch PJ. Vulvodynia: a syndrome of unexplained vulvar pain, psychologic disability and sexual dysfunction. J Reprod Med 1986;31:773- 80.
4. McKay M. Vulvodynia. A multifactorial clinical problem. Arch Dermatol 1989;125:256-62.
5. Paavonen J. Diagnosis and treatment of vulvodynia. Ann Med 1995;27:175-81.
6. McKay M. Vulvitis and vulvovaginitis: cutaneous considerations. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1991;165: 1176-82.
7. Gottleb A. Post traumatic stress disorder and vulvar pain. The Vulvar Pain Newsletter. Graham, N.C.: Vulvar Pain Foundation, Fall 1995.
8. McKay M. Subsets of vulvodynia. J Reprod Med 1988;33:695-8.
9. Turner ML, Marinoff SC. Association of human papillomavirus with vulvodynia and the vulvar vestibulitis syndrome. J Reprod Med 1988;33:533-7.
10. Umpierre SA, Kaufman RH, Adam E, Woods KV, Adler-Storthz K. Human papillomavirus DNA in tissue biopsy specimens of vulvar vestibulitis patients treated with interferon. Obstet Gynecol 1991:78: 693-5.
11. Wilkinson EJ, Guerrero E, Daniel R, Shah K, Stone IK, Hardt NS, et al. Vulvar vestibulitis is rarely associated with human papillomavirus infection types 6, 11, 16, or 18. Int J Gynecol Pathol 1993;12: 344-9.
12. Bazin S, Bouchard C, Brisson J, Morin C, Meisels A, Fortier M. Vulvar vestibulitis syndrome: an exploratory case-control study. Obstet Gynecol 1994; 83:47-50.
13. Bornstein J, Shapiro S, Rahat M, Goldshmid N, Goldik Z, Abramovici H, et al. Polymerase chain reaction search for viral etiology of vulvar vestibulitis syndrome. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;175:139-44.
14. Witkin SS, Jeremias J, Ledger WJ. Recurrent vaginitis as a result of sexual transmission of IgE antibodies. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1988;159:32-6.
15. Ashman RB, Ott AK. Autoimmunity as a factor in recurrent vaginal candidosis and the minor vestibular gland syndrome. J Reprod Med 1989;34:264-6.
16. McKay M. Dysesthetic ("essential") vulvodynia. Treatment with amitriptyline. J Reprod Med 1993; 38:9-13.
17. Turner ML, Marinoff SC. Pudendal neuralgia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1991;165:1233-6.
18. Fischer GO. The commonest causes of symptomatic vulvar disease: a dermatologist's perspective. Australas J Dermatol 1996;37:12-8.
19. Apgar BS, Cox JT. Differentiating normal and abnormal findings of the vulva. Am Fam Physician 1996;53:1171-80.
20. Bergeron C, Ferenczy A, Richart RM, Guralnick M. Micropapillomatosis labialis appears unrelated to human papillomavirus. Obstet Gynecol 1990;76: 281-6.
21. Welch JM, Nayagam M, Parry G, Das R, Campbell M, Whatley J, et al. What is vestibular papillomatosis? A study of its prevalence, aetiology and natural history. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1993;100: 939-42.
22. McKay M, Frankman O, Horowitz BJ, Lecart C, Micheletti L, Ridley CM, et al. Vulvar vestibulitis and vestibular papillomatosis. Report of the ISSVD Committee on Vulvodynia. J Reprod Med 1991; 36:413-5.
23. Woodruff JD, Parmley TH. Infection of the minor vestibular gland. Obstet Gynecol 1983;62:609-12.
24. Mann MS, Kaufman RH, Brown D Jr, Adam E. Vulvar vestibulitis: significant clinical variables and treatment outcome. Obstet Gynecol 1992;79:122-5.
25. Solomons CC, Melmed MH, Heitler SM. Calcium citrate for vulvar vestibulitis. A case report. J Reprod Med 1991;36:879-82.
26. Marinoff SC, Turner ML. Vulvar vestibulitis syndrome: an overview. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1991; 165:1228-33.
27. Woodruff JD, Friedrich EG Jr. The vestibule. Clin Obstet Gynecol 1985;28:134-41.
28. Reid R, Omoto KH, Precop SL, Berman NR, Rutledge LH, Dean SM, et al. Flashlamp-excited dye laser therapy of idiopathic vulvodynia is safe and efficacious. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1995;172:1684-701.
29. Stewart DE, Reicher AE, Gerulath AH, Boydell KM. Vulvodynia and psychological distress. Obstet Gynecol 1994;84:587-90.
JULIUS F. METTS, M.D., is an assistant clinical professor in family practice at the University of California, Davis, School of Medicine and an associate physician at the Cowell Student Health Clinic. He received his medical degree from East Carolina University School of Medicine, Greenville, N.C., and completed a residency in family practice at San Bernardino County Medical Center, San Bernardino, Calif.
Address correspondence to Julius F. Metts, M.D., 1717 Cork Place, Davis, CA 95616. Reprints are not available from the author.
COPYRIGHT 1999 American Academy of Family Physicians
COPYRIGHT 2000 Gale Group