Why We Need Critical Thinking. Robert E. Bartholomew and Benjamin Radford. Prometheus Books, 2003. 229 pp, $20, softcover. A series of case studies in critical thinking, intended so that readers can examine some quite specific topics along with the authors and see where they lead. The authors even urge readers to question or challenge the authors' own analyses of the topics, a practice that is a key hallmark of science. The topics include the Martian panic of 1938, the Roswell "flying saucer" crash of 1947, the "mad gasser" of Mattoon, the "jumping Frenchmen" of Maine, New England's great airship hoax, genital-shrinking scares, the dancing mania of the Middle Ages, the birthplace of the flying saucer, England's black helicopters, and India's "Monkey Man" mania. A final chapter is on "How to Recognize Mass Delusions." Bartholomew (a sociologist) and Radford (SKEPTICAL INQUIRER's managing editor) show that cultural assumptions play a large part in our judgments and that critical reaso ning is the best means of ensuring an objective perspective.
COPYRIGHT 2003 Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal
COPYRIGHT 2003 Gale Group