Furukawa TA, McGuire H, Barbui C. Meta-analysis of effects and side effects of low dosage tricyclic antidepressants in depression: systematic review. BMJ 2002; 325:991-995.
* PRACTICE RECOMMENDATIONS
Minimum effective dosage and ranges for antidepressants have not been established. While studies suggest that lower-dose tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) may be as effective as higher-dose TCAs, dose comparison studies with other antidepressants have not been conducted.
Low-dose TCAs may not be as effective as standard doses, but they do have fewer treatment dropouts due to side effects, and thus patients may have better long-term compliance. Regular monitoring of patient rate of reduction in severity of depression should be used to help determine optimal individual dosing.
* BACKGROUND
Despite widespread marketing of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and other newer antidepressants, TCAs are prescribed as often as SSRIs (albeit not all of these prescriptions are for major depressive disorder). Yet evidence regarding the efficacy of TCAs is limited.
Although many guidelines recommend TCAs in higher doses (100 mg/day to 125 mg/day), the effectiveness of lower doses of TCAs is not clear.
* POPULATION STUDIED
The authors performed a comprehensive search of the Cochrane Collaboration's Depression, Anxiety and Neurosis Controlled Trials Registry (a compilation of studies in MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, PsychINFO, PSYINDEX, and LILACS). They also searched major psychiatric and medical journals, ultimately identifying 2418 studies. After excluding trials that didn't meet their criteria, they had 39 double-blind, randomized-controlled trials for inclusion. Six of 39 trials compared low-dose TCAs with standard doses of TCAs (551 participants), and 35 of 39 trials compared low-dose TCAs with placebo (2013 participants).
TCAs studied included amitriptyline, imipramine, clomipramine, doxepin, dothiepin, trimipramine, and lofepramine. Ten studies focused on use of TCAs in primary care and 12 studies in psychiatric settings. Five studies examined patients aged >65 years, and 6 dealt with depression and comorbidities (migraine or rheumatoid arthritis).
* STUDY DESIGN AND VALIDITY
Two authors determined independently whether studies met inclusion criteria, and then graded the eligible studies for quality. The studies included were not consistent for population (primary care vs psychiatric, comorbidities, and definition of depression), medication and duration of treatment (4 to 52 weeks), and outcomes measured. Significant heterogeneity existed only for the response rates at 4 to 6 weeks in the TCA vs placebo groups. When the smallest 5 studies reporting the differences were excluded, the results were no longer heterogeneous.
The authors assessed individual study quality using the Cochrane Collaboration Handbook, focusing on allocation concealment and double-blinding. The authors used "per protocol" analysis, examining only data where patients stayed on the medication--dropouts were handled either by analyzing them by the primary study (last observation carried forward) or by worst-case scenario, intention-to-treat analysis.
* OUTCOMES MEASURED
Outcomes included response rates at 4 weeks, 6 to 8 weeks, and 3 to 12 months.
* RESULTS
Low-dose TCAs (75-100 mg/day) were more likely than placebo to bring about a response at 4 weeks (relative risk (RR)=1.65; 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.36-2.00, number needed to treat [NNT] [benefit]=6), 6 to 8 weeks (RR=1.47; 95% CI=1.12-1.94, NNT [benefit]=5), and 3 to 12 months (RR=2.14; 95% CI=1.41-3.26, NNT [benefit]=3).
Standard-dose TCAs were not significantly more effective at achieving response than low-dose TCAs at 4 weeks or at 6 to 8 weeks. In elderly people, TCAs were more likely to produce a result at 4 to 6 weeks but were also more likely to cause at least one side effect. Results were similar in primary care and psychiatric settings.
Overall, dropout rates were similar (24%) for placebo, low-dose, and standard-dose TCAs. Compared with placebo, low-dose TCAs caused more dropouts due to side effects; compared with standard-dose TCA, low-dose TCAs caused fewer dropouts due to side effects.
R. Eugene Bailey, MD, and Kenneth M. Johnson, III, MD, Center for Evidence-Based Practice, Department of Family Medicine, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY. E-mail: baileye@upstate.edu.
COPYRIGHT 2003 Dowden Health Media, Inc.
COPYRIGHT 2003 Gale Group